Egg Timer Get the app

Start eggs in cold or boiling water?

Both work — but the boiling start is the repeatable one. Lowering eggs into water at a rolling boil means the start temperature is identical every time, so 5:00, 7:00 and 10:00 mean the same thing in every kitchen. Cold-start results depend on your pot, water volume and hob power.

The two methods

There are two honest ways to boil an egg. Boiling start: bring the water to a rolling boil first, lower the eggs in with a spoon, and start the timer — 5:00 soft, 7:00 medium, 10:00 hard for a fridge-cold size-M egg. Cold start: put the eggs in cold water, bring everything to a boil together, and count from somewhere along the way.

Both produce good eggs in the right hands. The difference isn't quality — it's predictability, and it comes down to what the clock is actually measuring.

What the cold start does well

Cold-start fans have real arguments. The egg warms up gradually with the water, which is gentler — there's no thermal jolt as a fridge-cold egg meets boiling water, and some cooks find cold-started eggs crack less often because of it. Some also swear the shells peel more easily, though experiences differ and the evidence is mixed. And there's a comfort factor: no lowering eggs into a roiling pot.

If that's the method your grandmother used and it works in your kitchen, nothing on this page says to stop. The catch appears only when you try to write the time down.

Why cold-start timing falls apart

A cold start has no fixed zero. How long the water takes to reach a boil depends on the pot's material and width, how much water you used, how cold it came out of the tap, and how much power your hob delivers. Change any one of these — a different pan, an extra cup of water, a friend's kitchen — and "ten minutes from cold" produces a different egg.

The boiling start removes every one of those variables. Water at a gentle rolling boil is at the same temperature today, tomorrow and in any pot, so the moment the egg goes in is a true zero point. The only things left that shift the time are the egg itself — its size and whether it came from the fridge — and both follow simple rules of thumb. That's why every serious timing chart, and every egg timer, counts from boiling water.

If you prefer the cold start

You can make a cold start repeatable — you just have to do the standardising yourself. Use the same pot, the same measured amount of water, the same hob setting and the same number of eggs every time; run one test batch and note the total time that gives you the egg you like. As long as nothing changes, your number will hold. Change kitchens, and you start over.

Worried about cracking with the boiling start? Lower each egg in gently with a spoon so it never hits the bottom of the pot — that prevents most cracks. Piercing the shell beforehand is a debated extra: it helps some cooks, the evidence is mixed, so treat it as optional. The complete boiling-start routine is walked through in how to boil the perfect egg.

Egg Timer is built around the boiling-start reference for exactly these reasons: its stove and induction times count from the moment the eggs meet boiling water, so the presets mean the same thing on any cooker. The egg-cooker mode is the one exception — there the appliance itself is the standardised environment, and the timer counts the full run from switch-on.

Keep reading

A timer with a true zero point

Egg Timer counts from the moment your eggs meet boiling water — presets for stove, induction and egg cooker, and an alarm that rings even on silent.

Download on the App Store

Coming soon to the App Store

Frequently asked questions

Which method makes eggs easier to peel?

Some cooks report easier peeling with a cold start; experiences vary and the evidence is mixed. The more dependable lever is the cold-water shock after cooking — it stops carry-over cooking and helps the shell release, whichever way you started.

Do eggs crack more when they go into boiling water?

They can if they're dropped in. Lower each egg with a spoon so it never knocks against the pot, and cracking becomes rare. Piercing the shell first is a debated extra with mixed evidence.

If I cold-start, when do I start timing?

That's exactly the problem — there's no universal answer. Some count from switch-on, some from the first boil, and the right count depends on your pot, water volume and hob. If you cold-start, calibrate your own total time and keep every variable constant.

Are the 5:00, 7:00 and 10:00 times cold-start or boiling-start times?

Boiling-start. They assume a size-M egg straight from the fridge, lowered into water at a rolling boil, with the timer started immediately. From a cold start those numbers don't apply.